N-AERUS Annual Seminar
Paris, 15-17 May 2003


BEYOND THE NEO-LIBERAL CONSENSUS
ON URBAN DEVELOPMENT:
OTHER VOICES FROM EUROPE AND THE SOUTH

WORKSHOP PAPERS

WORKSHOP : HOME PAGE


Carole Rakodi
BEYOND PUBLIC FAILURE AND PRIVATE SUCCESS: DISENTANGLING THEORY, PRACTICE AND OUTCOMES IN THE PROVISION OF URBAN ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH SERVICES

Download the draft paper in RTF format
Download the draft paper in PDF format

Abstract

One response to widespread failure in public sector service delivery has been to challenge conventional models for provision, on both theoretical and practical grounds. The theoretical arguments are discussed first, and the resulting assumptions on which recent reform efforts, especially private sector participation, have been based are identified. Water supply, sanitation and solid waste management are then discussed in turn, although it is recognised that they are closely related to each other and should not be considered in isolation. First, the key issues which need to be considered in planning for improved supply are identified, and then each section reviews alternative arrangements for the allocation of organisational responsibilities and examines the outcomes of recent organisational changes and attempts to improve delivery. The arguments are illustrated with case studies and research on the views of users. The paper concludes that a more nuanced view than those provided either by neo-liberal critiques of public sector provision or statist condemnations of privatisation are needed.

BACKGROUND PAPER

CALL FOR PAPERS

WORKSHOP PAPERS

CONTACTS



N-AERUS Annual workshop - Paris, 15-17 May 2003

N-AERUS: Network-Association of European Researchers on Urbanisation in the South
http://www.naerus.net